Consent Debate Renewed by Brand and Walliams Allegations
The current age of sexual consent in Britain was established in 1885 following the high-profile case of Eliza Armstrong, a 13-year-old girl sold into sexual exploitation by her mother.
While the law has remained largely unchanged for over 140 years, recent public scrutiny regarding relationships between older celebrities and teenagers has renewed calls for a legal overhaul.
The original legislation, known as Stead’s Act, was driven by a sensationalist campaign led by W.T. Stead, the editor of the Pall Mall Gazette. The resulting public outcry, which included a march of 250,000 people in Hyde Park, pressured Parliament to raise the age of consent from 13 to 16.
Contemporary Legal Challenges
The debate has resurfaced following allegations of sexual misconduct against entertainers Russell Brand and David Walliams. Investigations, including those by The Guardian, revealed that both men had sexual relationships with 16-year-olds while they were in their 30s. Walliams has denied the allegations of grooming and misconduct.
In response, campaigners and survivors have proposed a "staggered" age of consent. This model would make sexual relationships illegal if the adult is more than four years older than the 16- or 17-year-old partner. Mia Latter, who alleged she was raped by Brand when she was 16 and he was 30, told The Guardian that she believes adults should be prohibited from having sexual relationships with anyone under 18.
“We don't believe [they are] old enough to consent to having sex with much older adults,” Layla Stone, a social worker leading the Close the Consent Gap campaign, told The Guardian. "We don’t believe [they are] old enough to consent to having sex with much older adults," Stone told The Guardian.
Legal Age of Consent Varies Globally Due to Historical Moralism
The definition of adulthood remains inconsistent across global legal systems. While the age of consent is 16 in most of the UK, it varies elsewhere.

| Region | Age of Consent |
|---|---|
| Italy, Germany, Brazil | 14 |
| France, Sweden | 15 |
| Ireland, Cyprus, South Australia | 17 |
| California, Florida | 18 |
Laura Lammasniemi, an assistant professor of law at the University of Warwick, said that these boundaries are often rooted in historical moralism rather than physical maturity. She told The Guardian that the 1885 law specifically targeted unmarried girls, while marriage for female children remained legal at 12 until 1929.
Former Supreme Court Justice Lord Sumption warned against reactionary legislative changes. Writing for The Telegraph, he argued that the law is an unsuitable tool for regulating the "infinite variety of human experience" and that imposing crude age-based distinctions could inadvertently criminalize innocent and happy relationships.
The government is “considering” a change in the law which would stagger the age of consent in the wake of allegations against Russell Brand and David Walliams. The Independent spoke to the founder of Close The Consent Gap. pic.twitter.com/5t3kB9ad9H
Brain Development and Complex Transitions Define Modern Adulthood
Rachel Thomson, a professor of childhood and youth studies at the University of Sussex, told The Guardian that the transition to independence is now more complex and precarious for young people.
Research cited by Sarah-Jayne Blakemore, a professor of psychology and cognitive neuroscience at the University of Cambridge, indicates that the human brain continues to develop into the late 20s, suggesting that "adulthood" is a continuous process rather than a point marked by a single birthday.
As policymakers weigh these arguments, research from the Nuffield Foundation suggests that current support systems often fail because they create an abrupt "cliff edge" at age 18.
Carey Oppenheim, an expert in social policy, said that early adulthood should be recognized as a distinct phase of life rather than a sudden transition. Further discussions on potential reforms to the age of consent are expected to continue as campaigners push for legislative review.
More on Eliza Armstrong
A Scottish Government minister has weighed in on the debate over changing the age of consent laws to protect 16- and 17-year-olds from older adults following the allegations made against Russell Brand and David Walliams https://t.co/2g94QiMt48