CBSA Demotes Officers Over Inability to Carry Sidearm
Border officers facing medical restrictions must accept lower-paid roles without salary protection under a new Canada Border Services Agency directive.
Sixty-three employees received notices that they must transition to positions that do not require carrying a sidearm, CBC reported. The affected personnel represent less than one per cent of the 8,500 front-line CBSA positions that require firearms.
“We think it’s discriminatory, it’s arbitrary and it’s unfair,” said Mark Weber, president of the Customs and Immigration Union.
The agency stated it provides temporary accommodations for staff unable to carry weapons due to medical or psychological conditions. However, personnel requiring permanent adjustments must move to roles where a firearm is not a condition of employment.
The union argues that the agency is penalizing experienced staff for workplace injuries or health issues that stop them from requalifying for firearm use every two years. Weber said that the agency is needlessly losing workers with decades of experience.
“Essentially, they are being told by their employer that they no longer have value simply because they can no longer carry a firearm,” Weber said.
One affected employee described receiving the notice as impersonal and bureaucratic. The worker spoke on the condition of anonymity.
“I felt like a file being closed, not a human being,” the employee told CBC. “The firearm never helped me do that job. My experience did. That experience didn’t disappear when I stopped being able to carry my gun.”
Beyond the 63 demotions, 14 employees on sick leave remain under review. Another 36 officers chose to retire rather than lose their accommodations, while 27 transferred to same-level roles and 50 returned to regular duties after medical clearance.
CBSA spokesperson Kelly Cameron defended the policy, stating that carrying defensive equipment is intrinsically linked to enforcement duties. She added that the agency must spend public funds judiciously and cannot permanently exempt staff from essential job duties.
Assigned placements for the affected workers will be shared in the coming weeks.