Skip to main content
World Today News
  • Home
  • News
  • World
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Health
  • Technology
Menu
  • Home
  • News
  • World
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Health
  • Technology
Castelli: Three-Way Nuclear Arms Control Stalls After New START Collapse

Castelli: Three-Way Nuclear Arms Control Stalls After New START Collapse

November 20, 2026 World Desk World

Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping pledged on November 19 in Shenzhen to open a trilateral dialogue on nuclear risk reduction, stopping short of any disarmament commitment, according to Zazoom.

The joint declaration “toward peace,” adopted at the margins of the APEC summit, reaffirms that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought — but contains no arsenal cuts, no new limits and no negotiating calendar.

That gap between what the meeting promised and what it delivered is the story. Analysts had expected little: American officials had framed the summit as a first conversation on a return to arms control, formiche.net reported. Nobody expected an agreement. What the three leaders produced was an opening — and a demonstration of just how hard a three-way nuclear bargain has become.

“The joint declaration commits the three powers to dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation, while leaving every hard question unanswered.”

Nine months without New START

The summit arrived nine months after New START expired, which formiche.net’s interviewee called “a bit of the elephant in the room.” Since February 5, for the first time since 1972, the United States and Russia have not been subject to binding limits on their strategic nuclear arsenals.

The collapse came in stages. Moscow suspended its participation in the treaty in 2023. In 2025, Putin floated the possibility of observing its limits for one further year — without restoring the verification mechanisms. The Trump administration, meanwhile, pushed for a negotiating formula that would include Beijing as well.

China refused outright.

Castelli: Three-Way Nuclear Arms Control Stalls After New START Collapse
Photo: zazoom.it

“China rejected categorically because it considers it unreasonable and illogical to take part in what it calls nuclear disarmament negotiations while its arsenal remains far smaller,” Ludovica Castelli, a researcher at the Istituto Affari Internazionali (Iai) and project manager of the EU Non-Proliferation and Disarmament Consortium, told formiche.net, according to Formiche.

Arms control, not disarmament

Castelli draws the distinction that explains the standoff. Arms control does not abolish deterrence — it rests on deterrence and legitimizes it, aiming to make it “more manageable and controllable.” Disarmament means a progressive reduction of arsenals to their elimination.

Washington asks for arms control. Beijing translates proposals into disarmament talks, because that framing lets it argue the first step belongs to whoever holds the largest arsenals. Xi’s Shenzhen call for the complete elimination of nuclear weapons follows the same logic: a distant goal that imposes no constraint today and that, in Castelli’s assessment, is unthinkable for the United States and Russia at present.

The arithmetic of three

The structural problem is numerical. The United States and Russia still hold roughly 90% of the world’s nuclear warheads; China’s arsenal is significantly smaller, though expanding fast and technologically advanced. Cold War arms control rested on parity between two powers. With a third actor, shared parameters become far harder to find.

“An equal ceiling for all legitimizes China’s growth; a lower ceiling for China asks it to accept permanent inferiority,” Castelli said. A quantitatively acceptable formula for all three, she concluded, does not currently exist.

The disagreements go deeper than numbers. Moscow and Beijing contest the American Golden Dome missile defense project. Chinese leadership attaches a broader political meaning to strategic stability — one that includes respect for its fundamental interests, starting with the fate of Taiwan.

Transparency compounds everything. “Without transparency there is no verification, and without verification there is no arms control,” Castelli told formiche.net, adding that arms control exists precisely because of the absence of trust. With New START gone, Washington and Moscow have lost the instruments that for decades gave each side a measure of knowledge about the other.

How the three arsenals compare

The asymmetries at the table, as the sources describe them:

Power Arsenal position per sources Stated position
United States About 90% of world warheads held jointly with Russia Wants arms control talks including China
Russia Same joint ~90% share; suspended New START in 2023 Contests Golden Dome missile defense
China Far smaller arsenal, expanding rapidly Demands disarmament by the largest holders first

What Shenzhen actually changed

Xi advanced one of the meeting’s most substantive proposals: regular high-level exchanges among the three powers and a communication mechanism for crises. The modalities and prospects for implementation remain to be defined.

The wording of the joint declaration leaves diplomatic space open but does not clarify whether the future dialogue will sit in a format dedicated specifically to nuclear questions. That distinction, Castelli argues, is far from marginal — given the risk that other great-power disputes end up conditioning the talks.

“Xi’s words on red lines show that Beijing ties great-power stability to its own political interests, not only to the nuclear question,” she said.

Whether the arms control dialogue can be at least partly insulated from geopolitical tension will therefore be the main yardstick for judging what follows Shenzhen. For governments, think tanks and legal advisers tracking proliferation regimes, the practical work now shifts to monitoring whether that dedicated format materializes — a task for specialists in international law and security consultancies as much as for diplomats.

Castelli, who holds a Ph.D. from the University of Leicester, where she worked on the ERC-funded “Third Nuclear Age” project, is also an Associate with the Project on Managing the Atom at the Belfer Center at Harvard Kennedy School.

At Iai she additionally serves as Interim Managing Editor of The International Spectator, and she is co-author of the book The Global Third Nuclear Age (Routledge, 2025). Her research, centered on nuclear politics and Critical Security Studies with a particular focus on the Middle East, has been presented at academic and Track 1.5 venues across the US, the Middle East and Europe.

The question left open is the one the declaration never answered: whether a dialogue on nuclear risk can survive when one of the three parties defines stability to include Taiwan.

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X

More on this

  • US Sanctions Comancheros Bikie Gang, Targets NZ Leaders Pasilika and Vetekina Naufahu
  • DuPont Cyrel Wins Premium Supplier at 2026 ABFLEXO Awards

Related

Search:

World Today News

World Today News is your trusted source for global journalism — breaking headlines, in-depth analysis, and reporting from around the world.

Quick Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Accessibility statement
  • California Privacy Notice (CCPA/CPRA)
  • Contact
  • Cookie Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA Policy
  • Do not sell my info
  • EDITORIAL TEAM
  • Terms & Conditions

Browse by Location

  • GB
  • NZ
  • US

Connect With Us

© 2026 World Today News. All rights reserved. Your trusted global news source directory.
For contact, advertising, copyright, issues email: [email protected]

Privacy Policy Terms of Service