Carpenter’s Unclear Remarks Fuel Doubt on Snyder’s Escape From New York Role
Zack Snyder may no longer be attached to direct the planned remake of John Carpenter’s 1981 classic action thriller.
Previous attempts to reboot the property stalled through multiple iterations involving filmmakers like Radio Silence, Leigh Whannell, Robert Rodriguez, Len Wiseman, Brett Ratner, Breck Eisner, and Neil Cross, before Snyder became attached in June to write and direct a theatrical package developed at StudioCanal.
Appearing on the Dropping Names with Brent and Jonny podcast, original director John Carpenter was asked about the remake and said that Snyder is no longer on the project. “He’s not anymore, but he’s trying to get back. He’s trying to get back. We’ll see. Nice man. I liked him,” Carpenter said, as reported by Dark Horizons.
In a slightly different recollection of the same interview, Carpenter also noted, “He’s doing Escape from New York. We’ll see, he’s a nice man, I like him,” according to Mandatory.
Confusion surrounds the remark because hosts Brent Spiner and Jonathan Frakes talked over each other in the audio clip. Frakes said that “Zack Snyder’s on fire,” and Carpenter’s sentence could have functioned as a reply to that exclamation rather than a direct answer to Spiner’s original inquiry about the director’s current status.

The interview was recorded months prior to its podcast release, during a period when Snyder was actively attached to the production and before his film The Last Photograph debuted in Toronto to a disastrous reception.
When asked if he supported Snyder’s vision for the material, Carpenter said that Robert Rodriguez is waiting in the wings with a new story concept. “We have a backup. Robert Rodriguez wants to. He has a new story he wants to do. So, we’ll see,” Carpenter said on the Mandatory podcast.
StudioCanal’s reboot centers on the 1981 premise where the United States has transformed into a totalitarian theocratic police state and Manhattan island serves as a maximum-security prison. In the original story, the protagonist must rescue the president after Air Force One crashes, with the mission complicated by the city prison’s most dangerous crook.
Former Special Forces soldier Snake Plissken, originally played by Kurt Russell, is the central figure. Snyder previously outlined an approach that sets the narrative in 1997 through the creative lens of 1981.
Regarding the audio landscape of the planned film, Carpenter asserted a personal requirement for his involvement in the soundtrack. “Oh, I demand to be the composer. Use my score. We’re going to remake the score,” Carpenter told ComingSoon.
Production on the project is aiming for a 2027 start date, with no official release date or casting details confirmed yet for the role of Snake Plissken. John Carpenter is attached as an executive producer on the project.
“We have a backup. Robert Rodriguez, he has a new story he wants to do. So, we’ll see,” said John Carpenter, executive producer.
Born in Carthage, New York, in 1948, John Howard Carpenter moved to Bowling Green, Kentucky, as a child before studying at the USC School of Cinematic Arts. He gained early recognition when his student short, The Resurrection of Broncho Billy, won an Academy Award for Best Live Action Short Film in 1970.
His feature breakthrough came with the low-budget sci-fi comedy Dark Star (1974), made for a reported $60,000, followed by the influential thriller Assault on Precinct 13 (1976) and the landmark horror film Halloween (1978).
Beyond directing, Carpenter has maintained a distinct career as a composer, releasing five studio albums since 2015, including the Lost Themes series, and scoring the recent Halloween franchise sequels as executive producer. In 2019, the French Directors’ Guild honored him with the Golden Coach Award at the Cannes Film Festival, and he received a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame on April 3, 2025.
Disclaimer: The views and cultural analyses presented in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Information regarding legal disputes or financial data is based on available public records.