California’s Voters Rejected Proposition 40, the So-Called Billionaires Tax, on November 9th, Even
California’s voters rejected Proposition 40, the so-called Billionaires Tax, on November 9th, even as ballot measures raising income taxes on high earners passed in several other states.
The measure would have imposed a one-time 5% tax on the taxable net worth of the state’s roughly 200 billionaires.
The defeat ended a direct claim on accumulated wealth, but the damage came earlier.
That contrast — a wealth tax rejected, income-tax surcharges advancing — is the story’s fault line.
“Today oligarchy has won.”
What Proposition 40 would have done
The measure would have required California-based billionaires to pay a one-time tax of 5% of their taxable net worth — business and investment interests included, regardless of whether that wealth had ever been liquidated. Proceeds would have begun in 2027.
Supporters claimed this tax would produce an estimated $100 billion windfall. The office also warned that taxpayer responses could reduce ongoing income-tax collections.
The departures came first
California avoided the tax. It cannot assume the departures reverse. There’s no obligation for them to return after defeating the measure, and most likely will not.
Maine already raised its top rate
This raises the top marginal tax rate for those individuals above 7.15% to 9.15%.
The two policies differ. California’s proposal taxed accumulated assets; Maine’s surcharge taxes only annual income above a threshold. Both, MPI argues, touch the same people — business owners, professionals, investors — whose residence and investment choices respond to tax signals.
The threshold problem
The open question is whether the California lesson transfers. Saez, the measure’s own designer, read the result one way. The Beacon reads the same midterms as a net win for taxing the rich, noting that three of five state income-tax ballot measures prevailed. Maine Policy Institute reads it as proof that even proposing a wealth tax drives away the people a state depends on.
Related reading
- Trump White House Warns Democratic Congress Over Subpoenas After Midterms
- Chelsea Women vs PSG: How to Watch UWCL, Live Stream, TV Channel, Kick-Off Time
- Waymo Halts Driverless Taxi Rides on US Freeways After California Ban (time.news)
- California Announces New Homekey+ Projects and Funding to Address Homelessness and Veteran Housing (newsdirectory3.com)