The Browns’ Quarterback Carousel: It’s Time to Move On From Shedeur Sanders
The Cleveland Browns’ ongoing quarterback situation has reached a critical point, demanding a decisive shift in strategy. As of October 7, 2025, the team finds itself at a 1-4 record, and the continued focus on rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders is proving to be a distraction and, according to many observers, a detriment to the team’s progress.
Since 1999, the Browns have cycled through an amazing 41 different starting quarterbacks – a figure consistently drawing criticism. With two first-round picks secured for the next draft, the likelihood of adding to that number looms large. Though, the issue isn’t simply a revolving door of starters; it’s the performance and perceived potential of those players.
The skepticism surrounding Sanders isn’t limited to Cleveland. Sources both around the league and within the Browns association express doubts about his current ability to contribute to winning games. This sentiment is reflected in his draft position; Sanders was selected in the fifth round, indicating a lack of immediate confidence from other NFL teams.
Despite a dedicated fanbase who attribute his struggles to the team’s surroundings, the reality is stark. The fact that Bailey Zappe – a name that has garnered significant attention - is considered a more reliable option by the Browns speaks volumes. The team is reportedly considering promoting Zappe from the practice squad ahead of Sanders, a situation virtually unprecedented in the NFL.
The current handling of Sanders is creating an untenable situation. Starting quarterback Dorian Gabriel is constantly questioned about his backup, and head coach Kevin Stefanski is repeatedly forced to address the third-string quarterback’s status. This constant scrutiny is a distraction the team can ill afford.
A potential solution lies in either cutting or trading Sanders. The Philadelphia Eagles recently released sixth-round quarterback Kyle McCord, who later rejoined their practice squad – a common practice for late-round rookie quarterbacks. The Browns, currently protecting Sanders on their 53-man roster to prevent another team from signing him, could potentially recoup their fifth-round investment. One organization member suggested trading Sanders promptly following his preseason performance against the Carolina Panthers. Reports from September 24, 2025, indicate that both the Baltimore Ravens and Philadelphia Eagles were prepared to draft Sanders in the fifth round. While trading within the division carries risk, keeping him in the building may be a greater one.
At 1-4, the Browns need to focus on solutions, and it’s becoming increasingly clear that shedeur Sanders is not currently part of that equation. It’s time to allow him to develop elsewhere, or to pursue other avenues to address the team’s long-standing quarterback woes.
