Brazil Senate Approves Lula’s $10 Billion Fiscal Package
SÃO PAULO — Brazil’s Senate approved President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s $10 billion fiscal package on Wednesday, a plan to slow spending growth and lift revenue that the lower house must still pass, after a costly reelection campaign left markets unsettled.
The vote came weeks after Lula, 81, won a fourth nonconsecutive term in late October following a first-round loss to Flávio Bolsonaro, ABC News reported. He had spent heavily to win the runoff. Markets noticed.
The package, per the reporting by AP News, seeks to improve public finances by up to 60 billion reais — about $10 billion — next year through new spending-growth rules, limits on corporate tax breaks and closed loopholes.
Reaction split immediately. Supporters saw a risk to welfare programs. Market critics called the plan too shy. Analysts said it leans too much on raising revenue rather than cutting expenses, and that perception has driven down Brazilian assets, including the real, the country’s currency.
The election bill comes due
The arithmetic explains the urgency. Ahead of the runoff, Lula rolled out a 15% increase in his flagship welfare program, Bolsa Família, or Family Grant. That measure alone will cost 5.8 billion reais ($1 billion) this year and around 22 billion reais ($3.7 billion) next year, according to Brazilian government figures cited by ABC News.
The minimum monthly benefit per family rose in October to 691 reais ($117) from 600 reais ($102). The average benefit will climb from 675 reais ($115) to 777 reais ($132), per AP News.
| Measure | Before | After | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum monthly Bolsa Família benefit | 600 reais ($102) | 691 reais ($117) | 5.8 billion reais ($1 billion) this year |
| Average monthly benefit | 675 reais ($115) | 777 reais ($132) | About 22 billion reais ($3.7 billion) next year |
| Fiscal package target | — | — | Up to 60 billion reais ($10 billion) next year |
Other campaign measures added to the bill: subsidized credit and debt-relief programs for small businesses and low-income earners, temporary federal fuel tax cuts, proposed zero-fare weekend public transportation. Congress also passed legislation shortening the weekly workweek without cutting pay, the Associated Press reported.
Who gains, who loses
Low-income voters were key to Lula’s victory, and the welfare increases are why. The same voters who carried him now watch the fiscal package that must pay for the promises — and some see their benefits as the exposed flank.
On Tuesday, students who had helped lead Lula’s charge to keep the presidency protested against the package on São Paulo’s Brigadeiro Faria Lima avenue. That artery hosts many of the city’s banks and brokers — the financial district itself, not a government building, drew the crowd.
Market agents sit on the other flank. For them, the plan does too little. That two-sided pressure — welfare fears from the left, insufficient-cutting fears from investors — is the challenge now laid bare for Lula’s fourth nonconsecutive administration.
A pattern markets remember
The asset depreciation of recent days has precedent. Lula’s victories in 2002 and 2022 also sparked immediate depreciation of Brazilian assets, and stock markets eventually recovered from high losses, ABC News reported. That history is the bulls’ strongest argument; the difference this time is the size of the election spending that preceded the fiscal repair.
One figure frames the gap: the package targets up to 60 billion reais in fiscal improvement next year, while the Bolsa Família increase alone consumes roughly 22 billion reais of next-year spending. The new revenue and spending rules must absorb that and more.
The lower house still must approve the package. Its fate there is unresolved in the reporting so far, and the plan already has critics on both flanks of the political spectrum.
Another open question hangs over the whole effort: Lula has yet to announce who will serve as his finance minister for the new term. Investors reading the package’s details have no name to attach to its execution — a gap the president’s own timetable has not filled.
Businesses weighing the limits on corporate tax breaks, and households tracking benefit payments, will both watch the lower house.
The pattern from 2002 and 2022 says recovery came eventually. The Senate vote on Wednesday starts the clock on whether it comes again.