Austin Audit Finds High Credit Card Spending and Weak Oversight Among City Employees
Austin must rein in a credit card program that let roughly 1,600 city employees spend $44.6 million in fiscal 2025, after a city audit released this week found weak training, thin documentation and almost no supervisory review — and Austin Current reported the recommendations will not be fully in place until October 2027.
The audit compared Austin with other large Texas cities and found the gap is wide. Fort Worth issued about 430 staff cards with $10.1 million in spending; El Paso issued about 450 cards and spent about $3 million. Austin issued 1,571 cards — about one for every 10 city employees, Austin Current reported.
Mayor Kirk Watson called the totals striking when the Audit and Finance Committee met on Wednesday.
“It is a startling number,” Mayor Kirk Watson said during the Wednesday session, pointing to how Austin’s overall spending stacks up against those other cities.
The timing matters. Austin just balanced a tight budget constrained by slowing revenue growth, property tax caps and rising costs, and the audit lands as Council members face pressure to show taxpayers the city is managing money carefully. No fraud was found this time, but auditors warned current practices raise the risk of it.
What the auditors found in 120 transactions
City auditors sampled 120 transactions across four departments. They found 21% lacked clear purchase descriptions, 35% did not establish why the purchase was necessary for city operations, and 32% had descriptions that only vaguely matched — or did not match at all — the attached receipt.

“Based on our observation, some Austin transactions are not documented in a way that would reassure the public that all City credit card spending is needed or appropriate,” the auditors wrote, according to Austin Current.
Approvals were looser still. Of the 7,381 transactions accountants approved in 2025, about 60% cleared automatically without supervisor oversight.
“Most accountants felt their primary role is to check that transactions have supporting documentation and an assigned purchase category,” the audit report read.
Fox 7 Austin, which also covered the committee presentation, noted some purchases were labeled only “out on leave” for $285 or “video” for $168, and one ChatGPT subscription was coded under “clothing.” The station quoted Ashley Rodriguez of the city auditor’s office: “Austin does not follow all best practices to safeguard resources as they are being spent through credit cards.”
How Austin compares with Texas peers
The peer-city figures tell the story plainly. Austin’s card count is nearly double Houston’s, the second-highest in the state at 867, per Fox 7 Austin’s report on the audit. San Antonio has the fewest at 370.
| City | Staff cards | Fiscal 2025 spending |
|---|---|---|
| Austin | 1,571 | $44.6 million |
| Houston | 867 | — |
| Dallas | 475 | $8.4 million |
| Fort Worth | 436 | $10.1 million |
| El Paso | 449 | $2.9 million |
| San Antonio | 370 | — |
Auditors said the heavy card use partly reflects a real benefit: the cards reduce administrative burden on departments. But they also found the city could retire about 400 active cards — more than a quarter — without affecting operations, because those cards are used less than once a month.
Council Member Marc Duchen asked auditors at Wednesday morning’s committee meeting whether cutting the card count sharply would hurt anything. They said the reduced administrative burden does save some costs.
A pattern of misuse since 2020
While this audit identified no fraud, it follows a string of misuse reports the audit itself catalogued, as Fox 7 Austin detailed.
- 2020: A staff member used a city card to buy at least $1.3 million in printer toner and resold it online, along with fraudulent personal purchases of electronics and home goods.
- 2023: An employee bought gift cards and firearm accessories for personal use.
- 2024: An employee bought a John Wick movie and changed the purchase title to “workplace shooter safety awareness.”
- 2025: A manager paid for contractor services on private property.
The audit covers cards assigned to staff by name and excludes Austin Energy cards, which were being transitioned by Austin Financial Services while the audit was underway, Fox 7 Austin reported.
What changes, and when
The audit makes four recommendations: reviewing and revoking unneeded cards, updating training and adding refresher courses, finding cost-saving strategies, and revising policies to strengthen controls. Training today is one-time and outdated, the audit found; other Texas cities require refreshers.
Austin Financial Services agreed to the recommendations. “AFS will implement an annual review process for all purchasing cards, define established usage thresholds, and identify underutilized accounts,” James Scarbaro with AFS said, according to Fox 7 Austin.
Austin Current reported the changes will be implemented by October 2027. Until then, the burden falls on department heads to decide which employees keep cards — and on residents and oversight groups tracking city spending to judge whether the fixes hold.
Watson is serving his second stint as Austin’s chief executive: he was the city’s 54th mayor from 1997 to 2001 before winning the 2022 mayoral runoff with 50.4% of the vote, and he was reelected in 2024 with 175,090 votes — about 13 votes over the threshold needed to avoid a runoff.
Between terms, he spent 14 years in the Texas Senate, where his colleagues chose him to chair the Senate Democratic Caucus and later named him president pro tempore, a post second in line of succession to the governor.
For now, the number on the record remains the one Watson called startling: $44.6 million, spread across 1,571 cards, spent in a single fiscal year.
Keep reading