Apple Pay Expansion Risks 300 Billion Won Annual Outflow and Payment Fee Domino Effect
As Apple Pay expands across the domestic mobile payment market, card industry projections warn that service fees paid to overseas firms could siphon roughly 300 billion won abroad annually, marketnews.co.kr reported on November 20.
The card industry estimates that if the service spreads from KakaoBank to other domestic card issuers, payments directed to Apple alongside international brands like Visa and Mastercard will reach that 300 billion won threshold. Domestic mobile payment services such as Samsung Pay currently do not charge card companies separate usage fees.
By contrast, Apple Pay operates under a dual-fee structure. Card issuers pay Apple 0.15% of each transaction amount while simultaneously paying international brand networks roughly 27 won, or two cents, per transaction for tokenization services, according to Marketnews.
Industry stakeholders express deeper concern over a potential domino effect across the broader mobile payment sector. If equity disputes prompt domestic operators like Samsung Pay to demand their own transaction fees from card companies, card issuers face an estimated annual cost ranging between 500,000 billion won and 1.1 trillion won.
The upper projection of 1.1 trillion won approaches nearly half of the total net income posted by domestic card companies last year. Tightening funding costs and lowered merchant fee rates already leave core profitability operating near its limits, according to card industry insiders.
| Fee Category | Rate or Amount | Recipients |
|---|---|---|
| Apple Pay Transaction Fee | 0.15% of payment volume | Apple |
| Tokenization Fee | Approx. 27 won (2 cents) per transaction | Visa, Mastercard, and international brands |
| Projected Total Overseas Siphon | Approx. 300 billion won annually | Overseas corporations |
| Potential Expanded Industry Burden | 500 billion to 1.1 trillion won | Domestic card issuers |
“Absorbing hundreds of billions of won in mobile payment fees each year is structurally impossible under these conditions,” a card industry official told marketnews.co.kr, noting that issuers will likely have to curtail consumer benefits such as no-interest installment plans or phase out popular reward cards to offset the expenses.
The transaction structure also routes domestic retail data through foreign EMV standards rather than domestic payment networks. This setup raises questions regarding whether sensitive consumer data, including purchasing histories, locations, and spending habits, will flow to foreign servers and weaken domestic payment industry sovereignty.
Financial and payment system specialists emphasize that policymakers must approach the challenge beyond simple market competition, protecting payment infrastructure independence and consumer welfare.
Founded in 2016 through a collaboration between Korea Investment Holdings and Kakao Corp., KakaoBank launched in July 2017 and rapidly amassed over 300,000 customers within its inaugural 24-hour period. The mobile-focused institution reached two million customers within a fortnight and surpassed 10 million individuals by July 2019, while also reporting its first net profit that same year.
“Our domestic card payment network boasts world-class efficiency and low fee structures, but if proprietary foreign tech payment standards become standard, fee outflows and the overseas subordination of core financial data will become entrenched,” a financial sector specialist told marketnews.co.kr, urging institutional safeguards to protect consumers and small merchants alongside the promotion of native contactless NFC payment standards.