Antonio Rüdiger Defends Kylian Mbappé Against Defensive Criticism by Citing Ronaldo and Benzema Success
Antonio Rüdiger has defended Kylian Mbappé against criticism of his defensive work, telling The Athletic that a forward who has scored 100 goals for Real Madrid should not be asked to do a centre-back’s job.
The German defender was asked by The Athletic’s Mario Cortegana about the Frenchman’s defensive output, after supporters questioned the work rate of Madrid’s forwards, mainly Mbappé and Vinícius Júnior.
“Should I tell Mbappe, who in two years, has scored 100 goals for Real Madrid, to do my job? It makes no sense. Look at Gareth Bale, Karim Benzema and Cristiano Ronaldo. Look at the success they had. We don’t always need to talk about them defending.”
Speaking via Madrid Xtra on X, Rüdiger put the same point slightly differently in the same interview.
“Should I tell a man who in two years scored more than 80 or 90 goals, who now has 100 goals for the club, to do my job? It makes no sense.”
He also reached further back into the club’s history to make his case.
“Go back in history. How it was when Bale, Benzema and Cristiano were there. Look at the success they had. We don’t always need to speak about them defending.”
The 33-year-old former Chelsea centre-back was speaking in an exclusive interview that ranged across his club, his teammates and his former teams, and came the same week he was honoured in Berlin following his retirement from international football, which he announced in September.

Mbappé has been one of Madrid’s most prolific players since arriving from Paris Saint-Germain in 2024, reaching 100 goals for the Spanish giants even as the team has struggled to win major silverware over the past two seasons.
That record has not stopped questions about his willingness to press opponents when Madrid are out of possession, and Rüdiger argues a player of his quality should be judged primarily on his ability to decide matches.
Sportsmole reports that Rüdiger’s comments do not suggest Mbappé should be exempt from defensive duties, but that the rest of the team must find a balance around attackers whose greatest value comes in attacking positions.
But a closer assessment of the same era contends that Rüdiger is overlooking key points: Ronaldo, particularly early in his Madrid career, was a great presser, while Bale and Benzema provided tireless coverage and pressing — Benzema even more so once he took on greater goalscoring responsibility after Ronaldo’s departure.
On that reading, the three superstars worked hard when it was needed, and just because Mbappé scores a lot of goals does not exclude him from defensive duties. LiveScore’s verdict is that Mbappé has made a start, but that there needs to be a lot more of it, and with consistency too.
The same assessment adds that it is not as black and white as Mbappé doing Rüdiger’s job: the centre-back is not asked to lead the line, close down defenders or cover passing lanes, which is strictly the Frenchman’s role. Madrid also play with 11 players who all attack at times, from corners or long free kicks, and must all defend when pressing and cohesion are needed.

The comparison carries weight because of what Ronaldo achieved in the Spanish capital. One of the most successful players in the club’s history, he scored 451 goals in 438 games, averaging more than a goal per game, and won four of his five Ballon d’Ors in Madrid colours.
Rüdiger also addressed the difficulty of managing a dressing room filled with established stars, referring to Rafael Benitez and Julen Lopetegui, whose Madrid spells ended prematurely.
“It’s not a myth. That’s the reality.”
he admitted, per Sportsmole, when discussing the influence of big personalities at the club. He additionally touched on Vinícius Júnior’s subpar season, saying the Brazilian winger is trying his hardest to turn things around at club level, according to Sportskeeda.
Madrid, three points behind leaders Barcelona with 30 points from 12 games, face Celta Vigo on Saturday, November 21.