History Teaching Now a Minefield as California Retreats from Ethnic Studies
SACRAMENTO, CA – A pioneering effort too mandate ethnic studies in California high schools is faltering amid political and legal challenges, signaling a broader national struggle over how American history is taught. Once lauded as a progressive step, the programme is now facing funding cuts and curriculum restrictions, raising concerns about academic freedom and the scope of historical inquiry.
California Governor Gavin Newsom signed legislation in 2021 requiring a high school ethnic studies course, designed to explore the histories and cultures of Latino, Black, Asian, and Indigenous americans. The courses frequently incorporate critiques of colonialism, frequently enough drawing parallels to contemporary issues, including the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. However, a concerted campaign by Jewish groups alleging the curriculum fostered antisemitism prompted a reversal. Governor Newsom’s 2024-2025 budget proposal omitted funding for the courses,effectively making them optional for school districts. The state Board of Education subsequently confirmed that school boards are no longer required to offer the course.
The shift reflects a growing national debate over the content of history education,with conservative activists increasingly scrutinizing curricula for perceived bias and progressive interpretations. The outcome in California-a state frequently enough seen as a bellwether for national trends-could embolden similar efforts to limit discussions of sensitive historical topics elsewhere.
in districts continuing to offer ethnic studies,restrictions are being implemented.San Francisco teachers are now mandated to use a single, pre-approved textbook that deliberately avoids the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and any supplemental materials require administrative approval.
Kairi Hand, a 15-year-old ninth grader in San Francisco, found the ethnic studies course valuable, recalling lessons on the Chinese exclusion Act and the discrepancies between Disney’s Pocahontas and the actual history of early English-Indigenous interactions. “Ther is a lot of controversy around the world,” she observed, “especially about what is taught at school.”
This article was originally published in the New York Times.
Read the original version (in English; subscription required)
