/2025/08/28/telephone-68b0583a4a9d7471750158.png)
National Rollout of Middle School “Digital Pause” Faces Scrutiny Over Cost and Effectiveness
PARIS – As France prepares to implement a nationwide “digital pause” policy in middle schools this fall-requiring students to store their phones during school hours-debate intensifies regarding the initiative’s financial burden and practical impact. The Education Nationale aims to curb distractions and foster a more focused learning environment, but concerns are mounting from departmental councils and educators alike.
The policy, which builds on recent experimentation, arrives amid budgetary constraints for local authorities. Last year, Départements de france estimated the cost of providing secure storage-typically lockers or designated collection points-at €125 million nationally. This expense is notably concerning, according to Nicolas Bonnet, a national executive member of the SDPEN-Unsa union, as “departmental councils have already curtailed funding for educational support programs and facility renovations.”
The core of the debate centers on whether the logistical and financial investment will yield tangible benefits. While proponents argue a complete ban on phones is frequently enough ignored, critics question the necessity of widespread infrastructure changes. Hugues Poirier, deputy secretary-general of the Snupden-FSU union and a middle school principal in Essonne, initially expressed skepticism but now believes the system can work. “I was skeptical, but we’ve managed to streamline the deposit and retrieval process with the boxes,” he stated, adding, “And it’s good for children to have a digital break within schools.”
However, Poirier’s experience contrasts with reports of disciplinary issues stemming from unauthorized phone use, including instances of students secretly recording teachers.The Education Nationale intends to evaluate the program’s success following the return to school, with potential adjustments based on feedback from schools and local authorities. The rollout will affect all middle school students across France, representing a important shift in classroom management and a substantial investment of public funds.
