Hidden Dangers Lurk in Popular Protein Powders

Dietitian Warns of Heavy Metals, Additives, and Misleading Labels

While protein powders are a staple for many fitness enthusiasts, a closer look at some top brands reveals potential health concerns, ranging from heavy metal contamination to misleading marketing claims.

Examining Ingredient Lists: What to Watch For

Registered Dietitian Nutritionist, **Violeta Morris**, highlights that not all protein powders are created equal. Consumers should be wary of powders marketed for meal replacement or performance due to hidden additives, fillers, and potential contaminants.

Many popular protein powders may contain ingredients that warrant a second look.

Garden of Life Organic Meal Replacement: A Cautionary Tale

Violeta Morris advises caution with Garden of Life’s Organic Meal Replacement Protein Powder in Chocolate. She points to findings from the Clean Label Project, which identified potential issues with heavy metals like lead, arsenic, and cadmium in organic powders. Interestingly, chocolate-flavored options, including this one, have shown higher lead content compared to vanilla varieties, according to data from Texas Health. Furthermore, the inclusion of erythritol, a sugar alcohol, can lead to digestive discomfort such as bloating and gas for some individuals.

Quest Chocolate Milkshake Protein Powder: Lacking Third-Party Assurance

Quest Chocolate Milkshake Protein Powder, despite its appealing nutritional profile, raises concerns due to a lack of independent third-party testing. “While its nutrition label looks solid—offering 110 calories, 3 grams of carbohydrates, and 22 grams of protein per scoop—the concern lies in its lack of third-party testing and quality assurance,” explains **Morris**. This absence of verification from organizations like NSF or USP means the purity and accuracy of its ingredients are not independently confirmed. **Morris** suggests opting for their vanilla version and encouraging the company to pursue third-party certifications for greater consumer trust.

Optimum Nutrition Serious Mass: High Sugar and Calorie Concerns

Morris strongly advises against Optimum Nutrition’s Serious Mass – Chocolate for her clients. A single serving of two scoops delivers an astounding 1,260 calories, 251 grams of carbohydrates, and 29 grams of sugar. “As a dietitian, the biggest red flag is the excessive carbohydrate and sugar content, which can lead to blood sugar spikes and unwanted fat gain—even in individuals without diabetes,” she states. “While it’s marketed as a mass gainer, this is not a healthy or balanced approach to weight gain.” The lack of third-party testing further exacerbates concerns about the product’s ingredient safety and accuracy, potentially outweighing any short-term muscle-building advantages.

Vega Sport Plant-Based Protein: Purity Worries Persist

Vega Sport Plant-Based Vanilla Performance Protein, despite carrying NSF Certified for Sport, was also flagged by The Clean Label Project. While it boasts a solid nutritional profile with 30 grams of protein per scoop, **Morris** warns about potential contamination issues common in plant-based options. “The Clean Label Project found that 75% of the plant-based protein powders they tested contained detectable levels of lead, with many ranking lower in purity than whey-based (dairy) protein products,” she notes. This highlights the critical need for consumers to be highly selective and informed about the brands they choose, even those with respected certifications.

Javyy Original Protein Coffee: Caffeine Content and Untested Claims

Javyy Original Protein Coffee offers a convenient caffeine and protein boost, but **Morris** cautions about the cumulative effect of caffeine when multiple scoops are consumed to meet protein goals. Each scoop contains 70 mg of caffeine, and while this is modest, consuming several scoops can lead to excessive intake, potentially causing tremors, headaches, and insomnia. Moreover, the product lacks third-party testing, casting doubt on the accuracy of its labeling and ingredient purity. The FDA warns that powdered or liquid caffeine can be extremely dangerous in high concentrations, with just one teaspoon of pure powdered caffeine equivalent to 28 cups of coffee.

Nutrition On The Go Whey + Creatine: Dubious “Lab-Tested” Claims

While Nutrition On The Go Whey + Creatine offers convenience, **Morris** points to the vague “lab-tested” claim without any third-party certifications as a significant red flag. Independent investigations, including those by The Clean Label Project, have detected heavy metals like lead, cadmium, and arsenic in numerous protein powders. At $2.67 per serving, this product is considered expensive given the lack of verified safety. **Morris** advocates for protein powders with proven third-party testing, such as NSF Certified for Sport, and suggests considering creatine as a separate, verified supplement from trusted brands like Thorne for better control over dosage and safety.

Experts Weigh in on Potential Health Hazards

Protein powders, popular for muscle gain and weight loss, may pose health risks. Several health experts share concerns about the ingredients and long-term effects of protein supplements. Consumers need to understand the potential side effects of these products, especially regarding kidney and liver health.

Protein Powder Composition and Effects

Protein powders, which come from plants, eggs, or milk, often contain extra ingredients such as flavorings and sweeteners, as explained by Dr. Sudeep Khanna, a senior consultant in gastroenterology. The amount of protein in each scoop varies, with muscle-building supplements containing more protein and weight-loss supplements containing less.

Dr. Khanna also notes that protein powders can significantly affect the gastrointestinal system. Many people have digestive issues, like bloating, gas, and diarrhea, especially those with lactose intolerance. These symptoms typically arise soon after consumption.

Safety Concerns Surrounding Protein Powders

Jeevan Kasara, director and CEO of Steris Healthcare Pvt Ltd, stresses the need for caution in using unregulated protein supplements. He highlights that many supplements include contaminants, such as heavy metals and synthetic ingredients. These ingredients present cumulative risks with everyday use.

“Whey protein powder and other protein supplements can have several effects on the gastrointestinal system. Many individuals experience digestive discomfort, especially those with lactose intolerance, as whey protein contains varying amounts of lactose. Common symptoms include bloating, gas, abdominal cramps, and diarrhea, which can occur shortly after consumption.”

—Dr. Sudeep Khanna, Senior Consultant

Dr. Kanika Narang from Indraprastha Apollo Hospitals points out that while protein supplements can help with daily protein intake, their use should be monitored. She notes the potential for health consequences from excessive or unsupervised use. A 2024 study found that 75% of protein powders tested had measurable levels of lead (Verywellhealth.com).

Possible Side Effects and Risks

Jeevan states that common gastrointestinal side effects include bloating, cramps, and diarrhea. Overdosing on protein can cause kidney failure and worsen existing renal conditions. Also, protein supplementation can be hard on the liver, especially for those not physically active.

Some protein powders cause endocrine dysregulation that can lead to acne, hair thinning and other changes. (Freepik)

Dr. Narang indicates that over-reliance on protein powders can limit dietary diversity, which can lead to deficiencies in essential vitamins and minerals. She also mentions that excess protein can contribute to increased fat storage, as the body converts surplus amino acids into fat.

Mitigating Risks

Dr. Khanna explains that people without lactose intolerance may experience symptoms like flatulence and loose stools. Nausea and indigestion can occur, particularly when supplements are consumed on an empty stomach. He also cautions that constipation is possible if protein intake lacks sufficient fiber.

Gastroenterologists reveal truth about protein supplements: Are whey protein powders safe for your liver and kidney? | Health

Whole foods such as legumes, dairy, meat, fish, eggs, nuts, and seeds not only provide high-quality protein but are also rich in vital micronutrients, dietary fibre, antioxidants, and bioactive compounds that are typically absent in isolated protein powders. (Pixabay)

Health professionals advise against long-term high-protein diets, particularly for those with kidney or liver issues. Dr. Narang highlights whole foods like legumes, dairy, meat, fish, nuts, and seeds as better sources of protein. She suggests consulting with a dietitian or healthcare provider to ensure safe protein intake.

Jeevan recommends minimal supplement use unless medically necessary and always under professional guidance. He says that a focus on whole foods is key to proper nutrition and mindful eating.

protein powders

6 Protein Powders Experts Say to Avoid Right Now