Giuliani to Newsmax: I Regret Hiring Comey to U.S. Attorney’s Office
Table of Contents
- Giuliani to Newsmax: I Regret Hiring Comey to U.S. Attorney’s Office
- Martha Stewart Case: A Turning Point
- Press Conferences and Self-Aggrandizement
- A Call for Restraint in Future Prosecutions
- Background: The Role of the U.S. Attorney
- Frequently Asked Questions
- What is Rudy Giuliani’s primary criticism of james Comey?
- What specific case did Giuliani cite as evidence of Comey’s alleged behavior?
- How did Giuliani’s approach to insider trading cases differ from Comey’s?
- What is Giuliani’s current legal situation?
- What is the meaning of Giuliani’s comments regarding “weaponization”?
Former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani told Newsmax on September 28, 2025, that he regrets his decision to hire james Comey as an assistant U.S. attorney, alleging a pattern of self-promotion and a willingness to pursue cases for headlines rather than justice.Giuliani, who previously led the Manhattan U.S. Attorney’s Office in the 1980s, described his initial assessment of Comey as “better-than-average to very good,” but believes that assessment was ultimately incorrect.
This revelation comes amid ongoing scrutiny of Comey’s career and leadership at the FBI, and also Giuliani’s own legal battles. The former mayor’s comments reflect a broader concern about the potential for political bias within the justice system, a topic of intense debate in the wake of indictments against both Donald Trump and Giuliani himself. The implications of Giuliani’s statement could fuel further calls for investigations into past prosecutorial decisions and the independence of the Department of justice.
Martha Stewart Case: A Turning Point
Giuliani pinpointed the prosecution of Martha Stewart as the first indication of what he characterized as Comey’s focus on publicity over sound legal principles. I thought the Martha Stewart case was the sign of a publicity-hungry, out-of-control prosecutor because of an needless case,
Giuliani stated. He argued that Stewart, unlike others, was targeted due to her public profile, suggesting that a private citizen would not have faced criminal charges for similar actions.
Giuliani contrasted Comey’s approach with his own practice as a U.S. attorney, where he typically handled first-time insider trading cases with civil penalties rather than criminal prosecution. He maintained that Stewart should have received a fine and restrictions on her activities, not prison time. He went ahead.He made a big deal out of it. He made a jerk out of himself doing it,
Giuliani added.
Press Conferences and Self-Aggrandizement
the former mayor also criticized Comey’s use of press conferences, accusing him of leveraging them for personal gain rather than acknowledging the work of law enforcement officers. I use press conferences probably more than anyone, but never for self-aggrandizement,
Giuliani asserted. He recalled his remarks following the September 11th attacks, emphasizing his acknowledgment of the contributions of police officers and firefighters, a sentiment he claimed comey lacked.
Giuliani believes that Comey’s leadership style ultimately paved the way for what he describes as politically motivated prosecutions against President Donald Trump and his allies. They’re the ones who weaponized, and now they’re pushing it on us,
he said, referencing his own multiple indictments, which he also characterized as politically driven. He went on to label these tactics as absolute Marxist tactics.
A Call for Restraint in Future Prosecutions
Giuliani concluded by urging caution in any future prosecutions undertaken by a new governance, advocating against what he perceived as excessive tactics. We don’t put leg irons on them. We don’t send the Gestapo into the Comey house at two in the morning with the press notified,
he stated emphatically. Don’t tell me they’re not fascist.
Key Decisions & Allegations
| Event | Date | Giuliani’s Claim |
|---|---|---|
| Comey hired as AUSA | 1980s (approx.) | Regretful decision |
| Martha Stewart Prosecution | 2003-2004 | Publicity-driven, unnecessary |
| Giuliani’s AUSA Practice | 1980s | civil penalties for first-time insider trading |
| Trump/Giuliani Indictments | 2023-2025 | Politically motivated |
Did You Know?
Rudy Giuliani served as the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York from 1983 to 1989, gaining prominence for his prosecution of white-collar crimes.
Pro Tip:
understanding the historical context of prosecutorial discretion is crucial when evaluating claims of political bias in legal proceedings.
What are your thoughts on Giuliani’s accusations against Comey? Do you believe political motivations influence prosecutorial decisions?
GET TODAY :
is the fastest-growing cable news channel in America with more than 30 million people watching!
Reuters Institute reports is one of the top news brands in the U.S.
You need to watch today.
get it with great shows from rob Schmitt, Greta Van Susteren, Greg Kelly, Carl Higbie, Rob Finnerty – and many more!
Find the channel on your cable system –
Sign up for and get , our streaming channel and our military channel World at War.
Find hundreds of shows, movies and specials.
Even get jon Voight’s special series and President Trump’s comedy programs and much more!
Watch on your smartphone or home TV app.
Watch anytime,anywhere!
Start your now:
© 2025 Newsmax. All rights reserved.
Background: The Role of the U.S. Attorney
The U.S. Attorney’s Office plays a critical role in the federal justice system, responsible for prosecuting federal crimes and representing the United States in legal matters. The appointment of U.S. Attorneys is a politically sensitive process, often influenced by the current administration. Historically, concerns about political interference in prosecutorial decisions have been raised, particularly in high-profile cases. The debate over the independence of the Department of Justice remains a central theme in American legal and political discourse.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Rudy Giuliani’s primary criticism of james Comey?
Giuliani’s main criticism is that Comey was overly concerned with publicity and self-promotion, leading to questionable prosecutorial decisions.
What specific case did Giuliani cite as evidence of Comey’s alleged behavior?
Giuliani pointed to the prosecution of Martha Stewart as a prime example of Comey pursuing a case for headlines rather than justice.
How did Giuliani’s approach to insider trading cases differ from Comey’s?
Giuliani stated that he typically handled first-time insider trading cases with civil penalties, while Comey pursued criminal charges in the case of Martha Stewart.
What is Giuliani’s current legal situation?
Giuliani is currently facing multiple indictments, which he claims are politically motivated.
What is the meaning of Giuliani’s comments regarding “weaponization”?
Giuliani alleges that Comey’s actions set the stage for the “weaponization” of the justice system against President Trump and his allies.
