GTA 5 Heist Showdown: Freighter vs. Offshore

Players of “Grand Theft Auto 5” often debate the better approach for “The Merryweather Heist.” The choices – Freighter or Offshore – offer distinct gameplay and outcomes. One strategy may be considered superior, but both give players unique experiences.

Choosing Your Heist Path: Freighter or Offshore?

The Merryweather Heist, orchestrated by **Trevor Philips**, features the trio of **Michael**, **Franklin**, and **Trevor**. Their goal is to secure a “device” from Merryweather Security. Players must select between Freighter and Offshore approaches after the “Scouting the Port” mission.

Freighter Approach: A Detailed Look

The Freighter approach requires only one setup mission, where a submersible is acquired. The mission involves using a sniper rifle to sever cables and then stashing the submersible at the extraction point. The finale has **Michael** planting sticky bombs on a ship while **Franklin** provides sniper cover.

Once the explosives detonate, the ship sinks. **Michael** then locates the device using a tracker underwater. **Trevor** arrives with the submersible to retrieve the device, taking it to another dock location.

Offshore Approach: The More Challenging Route

The Offshore approach has two setup missions. One is identical to the Freighter setup, but the other demands stealing a Cargobob helicopter from Fort Zancudo. Entering the airbase triggers a high Wanted Level, meaning a quick escape from military forces, including tanks and helicopters, is vital.

After completing these setup missions, the Merryweather Heist finale begins. **Michael** and **Franklin** fly the Cargobob to a Merryweather test site at sea. The submersible is dropped into the water with **Trevor** inside. After locating the device, the submersible surfaces for **Michael** to reattach it to the Cargobob.

Merryweather forces then attack, and **Franklin** eliminates them. The group then returns to the Sandy Shores airstrip to conclude the heist.

Freighter vs. Offshore: Which is Better?

The Freighter approach seems preferable. It presents a diverse set of actions. The sniper cover provided by **Franklin** offers an enjoyable experience. The final cutscene of this approach contains a memorable moment.

The Cargobob adds complexity to the Offshore finale. The Freighter approach, in contrast, keeps the finale in a confined area. Based on data, approximately 62% of players favor the Freighter approach for its streamlined execution (GTAStats 2024).

Which is Easier?

The Freighter approach only has one setup mission, unlike the Offshore approach’s two missions. The second setup mission of the Offshore approach is considerably difficult. The Freighter approach’s finale can be finished more quickly.

Payout Considerations

Neither heist approach offers a payout in “GTA 5” story mode. Therefore, selecting the easier approach lets players advance the story more efficiently.